Possible Exam Questions Elizabeth Essay
‘Tudor monarchs experienced more failures than successes in dealing with religion in britain in the years 1547 to 1587. ‘ Assess the quality of this watch.
Students may well refer to a few of the following materials in support of the claim that religious Policies were successful: On the other hand, there are a number of other factors to consider: • Religious improvements had helped to bring regarding rebellion in 1549 • Religious difference in Mary’s rule had been resisted by Protestant martyrs • There was continued evidence of Catholic survivalism beneath Elizabeth, particularly in the north, which usually witnessed a rebellion in 1569 that was largely spiritual in origins • There were opposition to the Elizabethan Arrangement from individuals who had experienced that it hadn’t gone considerably enough. Furthermore, students might legitimately point out that the capabilities of adjustment of religious Coverage were adjustable, as they had been dependent on the support of local officials who might not always have been completely supportive of the procedures themselves.
Historiographical approaches aren’t required to solution this question effectively. Yet , the effective deployment of perspectives created from historians just like Duffy, Haigh, Collinson and Lake will probably show skills of a excessive order. To conclude, students may possibly conclude that governments appreciated mixed performance in their endeavors to promote religious change.
As to the extent would royal power decline in the years 1547 to 1558? Students may well refer to the next to support the situation that hoheitsvoll authority was eroded: Nevertheless, there are numerous of other factors to consider which claim that royal specialist might not have been undermined: • Religious reforms under Edward VI, although undoubtedly unpopular, were pushed through callously • The legitimate succession was maintained in 1553, despite the machinations of Edward VI and Northumberland • In many respects Martha can be seen to obtain been an effective ruler • Mary’s heritage to Elizabeth was, people, positive. Furthermore, students might explore some of these issues in a historiographical platform, though this may not be required.
This may apply specifically to recent revisions of the reign of Mary. In summary, students should certainly offer evaluations which pull on a harmony of quarrels for and against the loss in authority by mid-Tudor monarchs. The rebellions which occurred during the reigns of Edward cullen VI and Mary My spouse and i were primarily political in origin. ‘ Assess the validity of this look at.
Nevertheless, there are many of elements to consider: • the western rebels were mostly motivated by way of a resentment on the scale of the attack upon popular faith based practices • the demands in the western rebels, whilst mainly religious, are also couched within a language which usually seems to suggest a significant amount of class antagonism • both the western and East Anglian rebels had significant sociable and monetary motives • it has been recently argued that conservative faith based sentiments were present amongst the East Anglian rebels • the overtly political determination of Wyatt and many of his guy rebels was reinforced by popular Protestantism of a number of his fans. In conclusion, applicants may differentiate between determination for the many rebellions.