The scarlet letter and the punishment of hester

Hester Prynne

“The Scarlett Letter” Thematic Article

Regardless of much somebody may be reprimanded for a extreme crime, nothing will be able to match up against the regret, guilt, and self-reproach that they may endure, because these negative mindsets can travel one to madness, or even worse, fatality. This concept can be thoroughly stated by Nathaniel Hawthorne in “The Scarlet Letter” exactly where two sinners would deal with their fate by possibly direct abuse or their particular culpability. One of the most significant styles that is produced in “The Scarlet Letter” is that the punishment imposed on us by simply others will not be as harmful as the guilt we all experience. This kind of theme can be gradually portrayed through Hester Prynne and Reverend Dimmesdale facing the outcomes of carrying out adultery, in which Hester has the capacity to overcome and adjust to her external punishment, but Dimmesdale struggles and faces huge trouble dealing with the internal remorse from keeping his bad thing a key from others.

Reverend Dimmesdale sustains a lot of internal conflict and pain throughout the new, being a faith based leader in the neighborhood and needing to set a solid example as a Puritan, although failing to keep up his purity after carrying out adultery and hiding this in fear of the consequences. This constant remorse led Dimmesdale to mental health problems which usually would convert to self-inflicted harm in an attempt to purify himself, however faltering to feel a lot better for what he had done. Hawthorne writes, “It was his custom¦to fast¦not in order to purify the body¦but rigorously, and until his knees trembled beneath him” (150). The guilt from Dimmesdale drives him to extreme functions like this, as well as until his “knees trembled beneath him, ” displaying the major result that this was having on his lifestyle. The main aspect of this can be that this was caused by his own thoughts from heading from someone who no one could ever be ready to commit however, smallest desprovisto, to doing something like marriage act, an extreme sin looked straight down upon by his other Puritans. In addition to this, “In Mister. Dimmesdale’s secret closet, underneath lock and key, there were a bloody scourge. Quite often, [Dimmesdale] acquired plied that on his own shoulders, laughing bitterly at himself” (Hawthorne, 150). Here Dimmesdale resorts to self-flagellation, the act of physically damaging oneself, an extreme example of the substantial suffering that Dimmesdale would go through from this sin. This steady harm that Dimmesdale puts up with is all from his personal guilt, without having third-party direct punishments induced on him except for his own, exhibiting the value of the results caused from your own guilt.

Hester has hardly any trouble dealing with her punishments and rapidly adjusts into a meaningful way of living. Within the new, Hester at first seems to be permanently outcast by simply society by being branded and compelled to wear a scarlet letter “A, ” but she’d gradually become accustomed to her punishment and make it a part of who she’s. Hawthorne claims, “Individuals in private your life, meanwhile, had quite pardoned Hester Prynne for her vulnerable place, nay, more they had started to seem upon the scarlet notification as the token, not of that a single sin¦but of her a large number of good deeds since” (169). Here the scarlet letter is expressed as a “token” representing her good deeds and displaying the normalization of Hester back into society, doing the opposite of the actual scarlet page was intended for. Even Hawthorne states, “The scarlet notice had not performed its office” (173). This further shows that the scarlet letter, something that was intended to penalize Hester, had not been fulfilling it is duty, which in turn conveys the idea that the consequence Hester confronts was not while detrimental to her as expected.

As Dimmesdale continued to significantly suffer and cope with the sense of guilt of his sin, his mental and physical overall health had swiftly deteriorated, leading him in to obtaining a personal doctor, Roger Chillingworth. Chillingworth, the husband of Hester, was seeking vengeance against Hester’s partner, as Dimmesdale’s secret became clearer to him, he purposely started a conversation about the nature with the problem that Dimmesdale was experiencing, exactly where Dimmesdale described that his “sickness” is at his spirit, becoming uneasy with the asking yourself from Chillingworth. After starting to argue, Chillingworth asks Dimmesdale, “How may possibly this become, unless you 1st lay ready to accept him the wound or perhaps trouble inside your soul? inch (Hawthorne, 141). Dimmesdale after that fiercely replies, “No”not to thee! “not an earthly physician¦I dedicate myself for the one medical professional of the soul¦who are thou¦that dares pushed himself between sufferer wonderful God? inches (Hawthorne, 141). Dimmesdale could not hold in his passionate emotions about the subject, as his guilt was driving him to an changed state of mind that was triggered by the anxious questioning coming from Chillingworth, leading to an unusual response from Dimmesdale as they were close friends up until now. The last thing that Dimmesdale wished at this point was for someone to find out about his secret, and this sustained remorse was the “sickness” that tormented Dimmesdale into a point of no come back, again focusing the passion of the injury caused by remorse.

In summary, the consequence imposed about someone by simply others simply cannot be when compared to magnitude from the destruction due to the remorse someone may possibly experience, as seen via Dimmesdale’s self-inflicted harm and suffering, Hester’s ease of normalization into society following her actual treatment, and Dimmesdale’s deteriorating mental and physical health. Hester and her scarlet notification become a mark of her transformation as she turns into normalized in society, facing little difficulty and problems. When compared to Dimmesdale, nobody besides Chillingworth actually suspects him of being Hester’s partner, however he endures more discomfort and struggling than her because of simply his personal guilt ridden feelings and cognition. This kind of comparison of interior versus external struggles reveals the massive influence internal feelings have because guilt, being an internal have difficulties, proved to get a major bad effect on Dimmesdale, while external struggles were easily dealt with by Hester, making it crystal clear that interior pain is far more destructive than external discomfort. No matter what the scenario may be, 1 will always be capable to see elevated devastation from the sense of guilt, regret, and remorse of committing wrongdoings, rather than the real punishment alone.

Tweet