Stem cell research t jones term paper
Excerpt from Term Paper:
In a discuss delivered to the Johns Hopkins Medical Center he stated, inch… we may want to let politics, viewpoint, and theology intrude on science. inches However , he goes on to meet the criteria, “science qua science simply cannot set its own ends… Scientists left to themselves may well not always associated with best integrity decisions (Nizza, 2004). inch
Here, Fukuyama alludes to another angle that may be less generally mentioned – that is that scientists and doctors equally can at times put their particular personal hobbies foremost in a ethical issue, including this one. Further, this is often financially motivated, “with any personal monetary stake in a biotech company to worry about, one example is (Nissa). inch However , he also chides those who imagine that “government” or in the case of the United States, Congress can easily or should regulate originate cell exploration, saying “by and large most Congressmen understand nothing regarding science… (Nissa). “
Instead, many around the front lines of the debate suggest that government authorities should “delegate authority” to agencies that specialize in the location under an umbrella of wide moral guidelines that all must follow. Further more specific agencies or concentrates of interest may be required to make more specific rules (human cloning, for example).
Although the meaningful question in the religious as is less likely to be resolved in a medical setting – especially one out of which no common surface on the issue of the sanctity of the embryo can be founded (a seemingly loosing battle given the latest legality of abortion), there is certainly little issue that most view the benefit of some type of regulation based upon ethical factors. Again Fukuyama states, inch… it should be legit under the correct regulatory environment to do study on embryonic stem cellular material. ” However, he goes on, “… I believe that the issue tends to happen when medication is used on nontherapeutic or enhancement purposes. “
Evidently the issue of control cell research is an ethically charged one, as well as perhaps morally irresolvable. Yet , given the typical utilitarian type of “it is useful for the majority of people, inch and that “people” are generally deemed by society as those who have passed the embryonic express, stem cell research is unlikely to end any time soon. Perhaps, instead of the debate above “should originate cell study be conducted” (a debate that has been largely lost for most parts of the world), the debate can move to simply “how” it will be conducted and how it can be applied in an ethical way. Again, this kind of thinking is definitely unlikely to assuage the feelings of those whom feel that the “good” being accomplished is at the cost of the sanctity of human existence. For them, the issue is likely to be the one that will cause much pain (and, perhaps later, should stem cell research prove powerful – very much quandary whenever they some day have the position to benefit from a stem cell derived therapy). One thing is for sure, that is certainly science ongoing to advance more quickly than ethical systems may adapt. Stem cell studies simply an example of many coming into the arena of modern argument.
Berger, Eleni. “Research Method adds gasoline to control cell controversy. ” CNN. com. This summer 18, 2001. Retrieved from Web site upon November 30, 2004, coming from http://archives.cnn.com/2001/HEALTH/07/11/stem.cell.fact/
NIH. National Study centers of Well being. “Stem Cellular Information. inch Web site. Gathered from Web site on The fall of 28, 2005, from http://stemcells.nih.gov/info/faqs.asp#whatare
Nizza, Suzanne. “Fukuyama examines biotechnology. inch Johns Hopkins Newsletter Apr 16, 2005. Retrieved contact form Web site in November 29, 2004, by http://www.jhunewsletter.com/vnews/display.v/ART/2004/04/16/407f343de8285
Shannon, Thomas a. “Cell Exploration: How Catholic Ethics Guidebook Us. inches Web site. 2004. Retrieved from Web site upon November up to 29, 2004, coming from http://www.americancatholic.org/Newsletters/CU/ac0102.aspStem-Cell Exploration